Casey's

Casey's at 627 S Main St in Monticello, Iowa, is a vibrant local favorite that masterfully combines the convenience of a gas station and store with the pleasure of a top-notch pizza restaurant. This unique tri-category establishment brings together fuel, everyday essentials, and crave-worthy food under one roof, delivering unmatched value to the community and travelers alike.

The heart of Casey’s appeal lies in its pizza, which patrons consistently praise as the best in Iowa. Imagine biting into a perfectly baked, golden crust topped with savory cheese and rich, fresh toppings that balance indulgence and comfort—this is what Casey's pizza offers. Long-time fans like Cat enthusiastically declare it “SOOO GOOD” and “the BEST PIZZA IN IOWA HANDS DOWN,” a sentiment echoed by numerous happy customers. Beyond pizza, the menu features beautifully crafted fresh sandwiches like the Chicken Salad Croissant—a harmonious blend of creamy homemade chicken salad nestled in flaky, buttery pastry with crisp greens and mixed vegetables. It’s an ideal light lunch or anytime delight, marrying texture and flavor in every bite.

Casey’s goes beyond food to brighten your day with its wide array of carefully selected convenience items. Whether you need a savory snack like their Original or Peppered Beef Jerky to fuel an adventure, or personal care essentials like ergonomic flossers and compact travel toothbrushes designed for on-the-go freshness, Casey’s caters thoughtfully to daily needs with quality and convenience in mind.

What truly elevates the Casey’s experience is its hospitable atmosphere. Reviewers consistently highlight the “incredible and nice” staff who imbue the place with positive energy, making every visit a welcome interaction. From attentive cashiers who earn five stars for their warmth and efficiency to fast, friendly associates who keep the service smooth and cheerful, the human touch here is unmistakable. Plus, with smart perks like every 10th pizza free, Casey’s proves it values loyal customers as much as first-time visitors.

Whether stopping by to refuel your car, grab a quick snack, or indulge in a delicious meal, Casey's on Main Street is a destination where quality, convenience, and genuine hospitality intersect. It’s more than a gas station or a pizza joint—it’s a community hub where taste and service come together to create something truly special in Monticello.